The OFFICIAL American Idol thread

[Natasha]

I really think we should have a separate thread for the new season...but I guess that's just me and I'm not in charge, so oh well. LOL

Anyway, David Cook is impressing me more and more...his performance tonight was STELLAR and oh so sexy (no surprise since it WAS the Chris Cornell version and Chris Cornell is like walking, talking, singing, breathing SEX for me...LOL). I was glad to see Michael Johns do so well, too...he was so cute last week talking about how he "apparently peaked in Hollywood." He needs to stick w/ those kind of songs...he actually reminds me A LOT of Freddie Mercury.

Seyesha was good tonight, too...enjoyed her performance. The rest of them I could take of leave. And CAN WE PLEASE GET RID OF THE KRISTY LEE WHATSHERFACE NOW!?!?!? UGH!!!

***EDIT***
And, to add, I've watched American Idol since the beginning (however I did miss most of Season 2). I believe, with the exception of Kelly Clarkson and Fantasia Barrino, the wrong person has won American Idol every year.

[debbie t]

david cook should win just for billie jean

[Natasha]

Okay...I'm watching tonight's episode since I had to work when it aired.

I thought Brooke White did very well and was actually graded a little harshly by the judges.

I didn't know the song that David Cook sang, but I didn't like it as much as his other performances. He still did well (and thank God for the haircut!!!) and I liked it, but it was probably my least favorite performance. He reminds me of Chris Daughtry sometimes...here's to hoping he doesn't leave the competition too early like Chris did (although it usually works better for their career if they DO lose, LOL).

I'm just not a Ramiele fan and tonight was no exception. She's cute as a button, though.

Jason Castro is just a cutie, in my opinion. I'm glad he had a decent week. Still don't think he's done anything to live up to his first two performances, though.

Carly is, without a doubt, the most talented girl on the show this year. I keep reading the Foxnews articles and they keep saying the girls are stronger this year...I keep wondering if we're watching the same show. LOL!!! I would've rather she done "Sparrow when she flys" b/c I think it would've suited her better, but she did good. And, Randy was right...the last note last week was AWFUL!!!

Sweet, cute, precious little David Archuleta...don't you just want to adopt him and keep him around the house so you can pinch his little cheeks??? LOL. If this boy doesn't win the competition something is seriously wrong. He is just amazing!!!

Kristy Lee Cook...can we send this girl home yet!?!?!? And what a tool to say she'd rather impress Dolly than her mom!!! She did okay...but I am just NOT a fan at all.

Totally didn't like the arrangement Syesha Mercado did. It switched too quickly from the slow part to the fast part and didn't flow right. She's got an excellent voice, though, and holy crap at that note she held at the end!!! If America likes her half as much as she seems to like herself, she's good. LOL

Michael Johns is still a hottie. He reminds me of Freddie Mercury, so he does well w/ those type of songs. I actually liked his performance...it was kinda bluesy feeling.

[Natasha]

Originally Posted by debbie t

david cook should win just for billie jean

It should come down to the 2 Davids in the end...at least that's my opinion. But, like I said, only 2 years have I agreed w/ who actually won...so who knows what will happen. LOL

[debbie t]

Originally Posted by Natasha

It should come down to the 2 Davids in the end...at least that's my opinion. But, like I said, only 2 years have I agreed w/ who actually won...so who knows what will happen. LOL

chris daughtry was robbed ,i think

[Natasha]

Originally Posted by debbie t

chris daughtry was robbed ,i think

That was on my Myspace page for a long time!!! LOL!!! However, he's done so well and it's actually BETTER for him that he lost b/c he's not tied down w/ American Idol's contract.

By the way, I worked security for the Daughtry concert that was here last October. I volunteered to guard his bald head, but apparently that position wasn't available.

[debbie t]

Originally Posted by Natasha

That was on my Myspace page for a long time!!! LOL!!! However, he's done so well and it's actually BETTER for him that he lost b/c he's not tied down w/ American Idol's contract.

By the way, I worked security for the Daughtry concert that was here last October. I volunteered to guard his bald head, but apparently that position wasn't available.

guard him ..i would have massaged his bald body..for free

[Natasha]

Originally Posted by debbie t

guard him ..i would have massaged his bald body..for free

LOL, me too!!! And have you seen his wife??? He's got love for the big girls!!! Okay, she's not REALLY big...but she's a little chunky.

[Natasha]

Omg.. was up w/ the 3 guy band that performed tonight??? Apparently they won some contest or something. Where, in hell??? OMG, seriously, I wanted to stab myself in the ears w/ a hot poker!!!

[Natasha]

Come on guys...doesn't anybody else watch American Idol???

Can I just say I am sooooooooooooooooooooooooo happy that the 2 that should've made it to the finale actually did.

David Archuleta vs. David Cook...it's anybody's game, but my votes go to Cook!!!

[Peter Parka]

I dont watch it, I prefer real music. All I know is that apparently Paula Abdul shagged one of the guys on there, is that a worthy contribution? Probably not, *back out of thread*

[Natasha]

Originally Posted by Peter Parka

I dont watch it, I prefer real music. All I know is that apparently Paula Abdul shagged one of the guys on there, is that a worthy contribution? Probably not, *back out of thread*

LOL...Paula can't keep her wits about her during the full show, I somehow doubt she was as crafty as he claimed. I loved it a few weeks ago when she critiqued a second performance by a guy who had only performed once. LOL

[COOL_BREEZE2]

Oh shit. I didn't realize this thread was here. I'll participate next week.

[Natasha]

Originally Posted by COOL_BREEZE2

Oh shit. I didn't realize this thread was here. I'll participate next week.

I think we need a new thread every season...but that's just me.

[COOL_BREEZE2]

Originally Posted by Natasha

I think we need a new thread every season...but that's just me.

Well maybe next season just start a dedicated thread for that season.